12/16/2009Without question, negligent supervision claims against schools are difficult to prove successfully. (For a rare instance where that claim has succeeded, see "Why A School Was Deemed Responsible For A Science Experiment That Went Awry"). But this task becomes infinitely harder when the child's claim is not appropriately investigated before legal papers are served and the case is begun.
In Tsai v. Duh, the plaintiff-student was struck by a vehicle that was passing in front of his school during the school's lunch break. Following depositions, the defendants moved to dismiss the child's personal injury action on different grounds. The driver of the vehicle that struck the plaintiff-pedestrian asserted that the child darted out into the roadway, and afforded him no time to avoid colliding with the plaintiff. The City of New York, on the other hand, claimed that since the accident technically occurred off of school property, they could not be held liable.
In responding to the City's papers, the plaintiff's attorneys asserted a new theory that they never before raised in their initial notice of claim or their complaint: since the child's school had a "closed lunch" policy, the school had a "special duty" to protect the child and prevent the child from leaving the school during this time, and they failed to fulfill this responsibility.
While even a cursory reading of this decision makes clear that the Court was inclined to dismiss this lawsuit, the Court's language in rejecting this claim should be taken to heart:
"This theory is not contained in the plaintiff's notice of claim or complaint. Causes of action for which a notice of claim is required which are not listed in the plaintiff's original notice of claim may not be interposed."
Category: School Negligence / Personal Injury
Labels: free book accident claims new york jonathan cooper long island auto accident attorney Long Island child accident attorney long island personal injury attorney negligence new york law negligent supervision New York child accident attorney personal injury attorney long island queens child injury lawyer special duty
There are no comments.
Post a comment
Post a Comment to "Why It's So Important To Investigate Your Child's Negligence Claim BEFORE You File Suit in NY"To reply to this message, enter your reply in the box labeled "Message", hit "Post Message."