In Dinardo v. City of New York, a decision that was handed down on December 1, New York's highest Court dismissed the lawsuit of a New York City school teacher who sued for the serious personal injuries she sustained when she was assaulted by a student. In this particular case, the Court held that despite the fact that this student had previously exhibited aggressive tendencies, and the teacher was asked to"hang in there" because something was being done to have [the student] placed or removed, the Appellate Court held that there was no rational basis upon which the jury could have concluded that the teacher justifiably relied on the school to assure her safety, or in legal terms, that a "special relationship" existed that would warrant imposing liability on the school. (For more on this topic, see "When Can A Municipality Be Held Liable For Failing To Protect You?")
In the words of the Court of Appeals, “[T]he vaguely worded statements by the plaintiff's supervisor and principal that was being done to have the student removed, without any indication of when, or if, such relief would come, do not, as a matter of law, constitute an action that would lull a plaintiff into a false sense of security or otherwise generate justifiable reliance."
Is it just me, or do you also find this decision very disturbing? It seems that this decision is fundamentally at odds with what transpires in the real world.
I wholeheartedly agree with the dissent's point in this case - that it is plainly wrong to penalize a teacher who went above and beyond the call of duty to continue teaching under very trying circumstances.
GET YOUR FREE COPY
"Why Most Accident Victims Do Not Recover the Full Value of Their Claim" is intended to help New Yorkers assure that they avoid some 10 simple mistakes that will almost certainly reduce the value of their accident claim, whether it results from a construction site accident, a car accident, motorcycle or bicycle accident, or even a trip and fall over a defective or cracked sidewalk.
The book addresses important topics including what you need to prove to win your accident case, and identifies some of the most common pitfalls to these cases. Click on the link above to get your FREE eBook on New York accident cases. Contact Long Island, New York accident attorney Jonathan Cooper at 516.791.5700 for a FREE consultation regarding your negligence case. There is no obligation to hire a lawyer. There is no fee until personal injury lawyer Jonathan Cooper successfully recovers fair compensation for you.